Are IQ Tests Reliable?

Are IQ tests reliable? Yes—professional ones are very consistent and trustworthy. Learn why most free online IQ tests aren't reliable.

Dr. Russell T. WarneChief Scientist

The short answer is yes, professionally developed IQ tests produce reliable scores. In fact, IQ scores are among the most reliable psychological data in existence. But like many topics in psychology, the full answer requires a bit more nuance.

What Does "Reliable" Mean?

In everyday conversation, people use the word "reliable" to mean that something is dependable or trustworthy. In the science of psychological testing (called psychometrics), reliability has a more specific definition: it refers to the consistency of test scores. When psychologists say that test scores are “reliable,” it means that the same person’s scores are consistent across test administrations or other circumstances, assuming the test taker’s actual ability hasn't changed.

This is similar to how a dependable bathroom scale will give you the same weight reading if you step on it, step off, and then step back on a few seconds later. An inconsistent scale might show wildly different numbers each time, even though your actual weight has not changed.

For IQ tests, this means that if someone takes the same test (or an equivalent version of it) on different occasions, their scores should be similar. The scores will probably not be identical because there is always some natural variation, due to factors like how well rested someone is or their level of focus that day. But they should be similar enough to allow psychologists to make the same inferences from the scores.

Note that reliability is a property of test scores, not the test itself. The same test can produce unreliable scores if it is administered improperly, or if the examinees do not belong to the population that the test is designed for.

How Reliable Are IQ Scores?

In psychometrics, reliability is usually expressed as a correlation coefficient ranging from 0 to 1, where 1 represents perfect consistency. Most scores from professionally developed IQ tests have reliability coefficients between .90 and .97. This is exceptionally high. For context, many personality tests fall in the .70 to .85 range, and even some medical tests used to make important health decisions show lower reliability.

The strong performance of IQ tests is the result of careful test development by experts trained in psychometrics. Professional test creators spend years designing items, piloting them with sample groups, analyzing the data statistically, and refining the test before it's released to the public. They document these properties in technical manuals and research publications so that users can verify the quality of the scores.

Different Types Of Reliability

Psychologists measure reliability in several ways, and scores professional IQ tests perform well across all of them:

Test-retest reliability measures whether someone gets similar scores when taking the same test at two different points in time. This type shows strong results for IQ tests, though scores tend to increase slightly on the second administration due to practice effects, as examinees become somewhat familiar with the test format and question types.

Internal consistency examines whether different questions on the same test are measuring the same underlying ability. If a test has high internal consistency, people who answer one question correctly are also likely to answer other questions correctly. Research consistently demonstrates that well-designed cognitive tests show strong internal consistency.

Alternate forms reliability looks at whether two different versions of a test produce comparable scores. Some IQ tests have multiple versions to prevent people from simply memorizing answers, and when these alternate forms exist, they typically correlate very highly with each other.

For a closer look at what IQ tests actually measure, watch:

Factors That Can Affect IQ Test Reliability

Even with a well-designed test, certain factors can introduce inconsistency into your scores:

Time between test administrations can effect how consistent scores are. This is true for all tests, not just IQ tests. It is natural that people change less over short periods of time than longer periods of time. Even when a trait is generally stable, like IQ, events can occur over time that lead to some instability (e.g., head injuries, health problems, new stressors). When there is a longer period of time between testings, there is more opportunity for these events to happen.

Testing conditions can influence results. Taking a test while distracted, exhausted, or anxious can lower performance. Professional test administrators work to create optimal conditions that are similar every time, and quality online tests allow examinees to take breaks between subtests to maintain their focus.

Measurement error is present in all tests. Even the most carefully designed IQ test has some degree of random variation. Professional assessments account for this by reporting confidence intervals around IQ scores, acknowledging that the "true" score likely falls within a range rather than at one exact number.

Why This Matters

The strong reliability of professional IQ tests is one reason they're trusted for important decisions. Schools use them to identify children who may benefit from gifted programs or who need additional educational support. Employers use cognitive ability tests for hiring decisions. Clinical psychologists incorporate them into diagnostic evaluations. These applications are only justifiable when the underlying measurements are consistent and dependable.

Inconsistent tests, on the other hand, are worse than useless; they can be actively harmful. If a test gives someone a score of 120 one week and 95 the next week without any real change in ability, it isn't measuring anything meaningful. Using such scores to make educational or clinical decisions would be inappropriate and potentially damaging.

Ultimately, professional IQ tests developed by trained psychometricians are highly reliable among the most consistent psychological measurements available. This is why they've been used successfully for over a century in education, employment, clinical settings, and research. However, this only applies to tests created by professionals who follow rigorous development standards. Many online tests claiming to measure IQ are created by people without proper training and produce inconsistent results. Anyone considering an IQ test should investigate who created it and whether proper scientific methods were followed during its development.

Author

Dr. Russell T. WarneChief Scientist

Contact

Article Categories